Audit Open Original ↗
Silence Laboratories Silent Shard
Type
Security review
Client
Silence Laboratories
Date
2024-02
Domain
Crypto
Effort
5 wks
Section
Cryptography Reviews
Trail of Bits's security review of Silence Laboratories (Feb 2024) identified 15 issues: 2 high, 5 medium, 2 low, and 6 informational.
Findings · 15
- 1 DKG implementation does not enforce length check of committed polynomials Medium
- 2 DKG implementation does not enforce zero-knowledge proof verification Medium
- 3 Malicious participant can cause panic in targeted participants during DKG Low
- 4 Proactive security model is not specified Informational
- 5 Parties use same session ID for all-but-one-OT Informational
- 6 Communication channels between parties can reuse nonces High
- 7 Parties may not agree on root chain code after DKG Medium
- 8 Inconsistent DSG session ID causes honest parties to denylist each other Medium
- 9 Messages from previous signing sessions can be replayed Medium
- 10 Distributed signature generation session ID is not tied to key generation Informational
- 11 Additional domain separation can improve defense in depth Informational
- 12 Implementation mishandles selective abort attacks High
- 13 Combining aspects of different protocols has unclear security implications Informational
- 14 Participants abort when receiving inauthentic messages Low
- 15 DSG setup validation does not verify threshold Informational
Findings extracted from the published report PDF. See the full report below for details and remediation.
Related